Best Of
Re: MCP Server
There is zero privacy with AI services. They remember everything you tell them and there is no expectation that it won't be shared. Every time I ask an AI service a medical question, pop ups come up saying "do not share personally identifying information" besides the "_x_ is not a doctor" (meaning no medical privacy laws apply). Heck, AI learned how to code by reading other people's private code (for example, microsoft's reason for owning github is so that it could use public and private code stored there to train it's copilot tool).
Recently, Google even announced that their Web-Based-AI-search-assistant will even have read all your e-mail and be very familiar with who you are from that. I'm sure Microsoft's tool is already trained on hotmail/outlook mail.
I also don't want an AI service making transfers between accounts for me. I have a tool like this so that -i- can see my financial picture. So I can make better decisions.
Why not ask for MCP access directly from your banks? You'd probably get more access and tools from them if they would actually let you do that.
EDIT: Also, AI tools work in their own self-interest, and may make decisions you don't want them to. As sure as AI can write bad code, AI with access to your banking could bankrupt you.
RobWilk
Re: MCP Server
They apparently modified ChatGPT so it will not give medical, FINANCIAL, or legal advice. I expect other models (Grok, Gemini) will follow.
RobWilk
Re: MCP Server
Before we get an MCP Server, I'd love to get a basic API so I could connect Power BI (or any BI reporting tool) directly to the quicken data and refresh it on a schedule.
tim40
Re: Remember Expanded/Collapsed Settings, Make Layout Changes Permanent (edited)
In the accounts section it defaults to expanding all of my accounts. It would be nice to be able to adjust the default to have all of my accounts minimized. Seeing the overall balances of banking, investments, Assets, and Liabilities is all I need a majority of the time.
Re: Does editing an individual reminder change the "Exact Amount" setting for that one?
Thanks for making a best guess answer, i will keep an eye on this going forward.
RobWilk
Re: Using splits (multiple categories) in Recurring Transactions (4 Merged Votes)
I had a similar issue last week, deposited two checks at an atm. Each check corresponded to a certain planned income. There's no way to attach each split to the series, so I had to just dismiss one of the reminders, connect the other reminder to the deposit, and then set up the splits. (If you do the splits first and then connect the transaction to the reminder, it wipes out the splits.)
Quite annoying since it means I can't rely on looking at the series history. To see the income history for that job, I instead need to search for the payee name (and I have to put both names into the "Payee" of the deposit).
Re: Spending Report Graph missing in at least some cases
Hello @RobWilk,
I am glad to see that you were able to get everything working as intended. I was unable to reproduce this issue myself, so it may have been a minor visual glitch that resolved on its own. In the future, if you encounter this problem again, I recommend selecting the 'Reset Report' option at the top of the report and then applying your desired date range to see if that resolves the issue.
-Coach Jon
Re: Ability to create a transaction from a Reminder (edited)
I second this request! I can't believe this isn't already possible!
Re: Using splits (multiple categories) in Recurring Transactions (4 Merged Votes)
Today I was reminded again why splits need to be treated as individual transactions. Apple is now billing multiple subscriptions together, and I have reminders set up for each one. But I can’t actually use them because I can’t assign the bundled charges to the individual reminders. Now I’m stuck with gaps and mismatches since the bundling is random.
This isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s a must-have. This is basic functionality for an app at this price.
Beltifi
Re: Running Balance Column [edited] (3 Merged Votes)
The issue here is simple, Simplifi.
If my bank account has 3 cleared transactions: +$10, -$5, -$3, today's balance is $2, and Simplifi shows me $2. Great!
But if one of the transactions (e.g. -$5) doesn't get imported or is accidentally deleted, my account in Simplifi will show transactions +$10, -$3, but the account balance will still show $2 because that's the balance coming from my bank.
Now, because the -$5 expense is missing, my spending plan data is incorrect, so my reports are incorrect, but I might not realize it because the account balance looks correct and might not raising any flags.
In this example, it would be pretty easy to realize the issue because 1 of 3 transactions is missing. But imagine if my account had hundreds of transactions? Thousands of transactions? Without a running balance, you're making it extremely difficult to figure out what is going on.
