I had two manual transfer transactions entered:
- a transfer/payment from TOTAL CHECKING to CITI COSTCO of $18.82
- a transfer/payment from TOTAL CHECKING to CITI COSTCO of $366.45 (this one is technically a future transaction, but it has a past date, it's scheduled for mid october)
When the $18.82 transaction downloaded, it changed transaction #2 to $18.82 and cleared it, leaving transaction 1 pending which is clearly the better (exact) match.
This was obvious once my current balance went from $0 to like $340-something.
I fixed this by hand, but thought it worth pointing out as I expect it's a bug.