Convert Reminders to a Transaction on the day they occur [edited] (1 Merged Vote)

EL1234

https://community.simplifimoney.com/discussion/comment/40013#Comment_40013

Yup, I already voted for that one too :D Thanks for posting it!

https://community.simplifimoney.com/discussion/comment/40015#Comment_40015

While I hear and agree, it is disheartening to watch new idea posts get merged with old and neglected ones, over and over. Hopefully the accumulated votes will actually make a difference at some point!

SRC54

I agree that we should be able to enter a reminder easily as a transaction, and I agree that it would be nice if we had the option to make it automatic if we choose. This would be very helpful for manual accounts since more and more of us have those and there are no downloads for Simplifi to match with a recurring reminder.

We also need the ability to add splits to Reminders since many reminders are split, especially the income ones such as paychecks. Without that Reminders will still be broken.

MishaM

Bringing this up to the top. Would be helpful for an asset cash account like a car to have a recurring monthly depreciation transaction.

IgnacioRG

Hope you can release this upgrade!! Its very important as its very time consuming. Many thanks

RobWilk

With time, I've come to realize I do not want this feature. While I do want the ability to convert a reminder to a transaction, I don't want anything entered automatically from reminders. I may schedule things that don't have definitive dates, and i'd rather have them move forward as a 'past due' reminder, than a transaction. Reminders are to remind me to make payments, and if it's auto entered, I will never remember. Also, what about the case where a reminder is income, and it gets auto-entered but is not actually in the account for some reason -it could cause me to spend money i don't have.

In short, I think I am now the first no vote for this idea.

egal

@RobWilk This feature is an option in Quicken desktop and I would assume that if implemented here, it would also be an option per transaction reminder as to if it should be automatically entered. If true, you could disable this option as you do not wish to use it. I think for many, we want them automatically entered as the payment itself is set up to automatically withdraw from the account. If the payment is a manual payment then I would not select that option, as you mention, because I don't know the exact day I will pay it.

SRC54

@egal Yes, I think you are correct, that if this idea gets implemented, that you could specify whether to enter it manually or automatically with each reminder. I find in Quicken Classic that there aren't too many reminders that I do automatically because the due dates change and so do the amounts. It works fairly well for some income and subscriptions. Otherwise, I do it myself.

Users need to be able to turn a reminder into a transaction, especially for manual accounts and we also need splits in reminders.

Also, there is another idea, slightly more basic that has a lot more votes. I think if either of these got implemented, they would include both manual and automatic. Vote for it as well, if you haven't already.

https://community.simplifimoney.com/discussion/1894/ability-to-create-a-transaction-from-a-reminder-edited

egal

@SRC54 for me most reminders would be automatic, but there is the occasional one-off bill that I would use the manual option for. I have already voted for the other idea as well. I would be pretty happy with either.

EL1234

I would definitely use "Ability to create a transaction from a Reminder" on a regular basis. Already voted for it :)